The Remediation Dividend: How to Earn SEC Cooperation Credit, and What It Costs to Leave Issues Open

Program Management
5 min

What investment advisers can learn from the SEC’s 2026 enforcement results

Summary

The SEC is rewarding firms that can prove what they did after finding a problem. Its updated Enforcement Manual formalizes how cooperation and remediation affect penalties, and this year’s settlements show it working in practice. CBIZ caught its own issue, fixed it, reported it and paid no civil penalty. For CCOs, the deciding factor isn’t whether issues come up. It’s whether you can show when you found an issue, what you did about it and how it was resolved.

The largest penalties went to firms that knew about a risk and didn’t follow through. UBS paid $20 million after a fix it had promised regulators years earlier never fully worked. Western Asset paid $100 million after its own CCO had flagged the trading risk in writing. For RIAs, the takeaway is to treat every documented issue as an open liability until there’s a documented resolution. That means an owner, a deadline, evidence the fix worked, and a record you can produce when an examiner asks.

What the 2026 numbers say

The SEC’s fiscal 2026 enforcement results extend a three-year slide. The Commission filed 235 standalone actions, down from 303 in fiscal 2025 and 431 in fiscal 2024. Civil penalties fell to $343 million, while money returned to harmed investors nearly tripled to $731 million.

A lower case count doesn’t mean RIAs face less scrutiny. The Division of Enforcement is bringing fewer, more selective cases, and this year it was explicit about what it will reward. Its first Enforcement Manual update since 2017 lays out how cooperation and remediation factor into charging and penalty decisions.

The question every examiner eventually asks

Exams rarely turn on whether a firm has a policy. They turn on what happened after something went wrong, and whether the firm can prove it. In a recent conversation, a compliance consultant who works with financial firms described how that plays out in the room:

“In a FINRA or SEC exam, they’ll see an email from two years ago that refers to a problem and ask: ‘When did you find out? What did you do about it? How was it resolved?’ Then I have to go through a lot of information to gather it, hoping it’s in a folder somewhere.”

This isn’t only a problem at firms with weak programs. As the CCO / CFO of one investment firm told us:

“We have a robust compliance program, and I’m confident in it. But Excel and folders aren’t ideal. When the SEC comes in, we have to go through all those folders to find an approval and the supporting documentation.”

For most CCOs, this is a familiar scenario. Answering those three questions quickly and completely matters during an exam, and it matters even more if an exam finding turns into an enforcement referral. Based on the 2026 results, those answers now have a direct effect on how a case is resolved.

Where the credit went

CBIZ is the clearest example. The company found on its own that it had issued more shares under its employee stock plan than it had registered. It stopped the issuances, investigated, reported the problem to the SEC, cooperated with staff and offered rescission. The Commission imposed no civil penalty and cited those steps in its order.

Key Tronic didn’t self-report, but its response to an internal complaint carried weight. The complaint arrived the morning of a scheduled earnings release in January 2021. Within hours, the company had confirmed the core allegations and told its board and auditor. It then investigated, quantified the impact and corrected its financial statements. The SEC credited that response, and the company paid no penalty.

While neither company is an adviser, the cooperation framework in the updated Enforcement Manual applies to RIAs the same way. In both cases, the SEC could see when the company learned of the problem and what it did next, because the company had a record of it.

Documented, but not fixed

UBS Financial Services had already been penalized in 2018 for failing to monitor foreign currency wires, so the problem was on record. The fix didn’t hold. UBS relied on a manual quarterly review until 2021, and the automated system it introduced that year left out roughly a third of FX wires in certain retail accounts. Between 2019 and 2023, more than 60,000 wires worth over $10 billion weren’t reasonably monitored. Even after UBS hired a consultant to run a lookback, it didn’t file the resulting suspicious activity reports on time. The SEC’s penalty was $20 million, part of $125 million paid to FinCEN, FINRA, the CFTC and the SEC. SAR filing is a broker-dealer obligation, but the same pattern applies to any control an RIA tests and marks as fixed.

At Western Asset, the risk was documented too. In August 2021, the firm’s chief compliance officer emailed investment staff warning that delaying trade allocations created a risk of cherry-picking, citing prior SEC cases. Supervisory and compliance staff knew the former co-CIO wasn’t following the firm’s allocation procedures. He routinely entered allocations after daily settlement prices were set and didn’t record his intended allocations beforehand. The firm didn’t take reasonable steps to investigate or stop it, and the conduct ran from January 2021 to October 2023. Western Asset paid a $100 million penalty.

In both cases, the firm’s own records showed it knew about the risk. What was missing was follow-through: at UBS, confirming that the fix actually worked; at Western Asset, enforcing the procedure compliance had already flagged. For RIAs, a documented issue without a documented resolution is harder to defend than most firms assume.

What firms should do now

  • Inventory every open issue. Exam findings, testing exceptions, consultant recommendations, complaint escalations. If it takes more than an afternoon to pull that list together, start there.
  • Give each one an owner and a date. Western Asset’s compliance team flagged the allocation risk, but the firm didn’t take reasonable steps to enforce the procedure afterward.
  • Confirm the fix worked. Closing an item should require evidence that the control now operates as intended. UBS replaced a manual process with an automated one that still missed about a third of the wires in certain accounts.
  • Capture evidence as the work happens. Rebuilding a timeline during an exam is slow and incomplete, and it gets worse as firms grow. One compliance leader at a growing investment manager put it bluntly: “The SEC exam was exhausting. We’ve grown, and people didn’t put data in.”
  • Connect issues to their source. A finding should link back to the policy, test or review that surfaced it, so the story holds together when an examiner pulls the thread.

Close the loop before someone asks

Skematic brings tasks, testing, policies and case management into one connected system. When a reviewer flags an issue, it’s assigned an owner, a deadline and an audit trail in the same place the work happened. When an examiner asks when you found out, what you did and how it was resolved, the record is already there.

As one CCO told us, the goal is to “give the SEC the output in a nice, pretty bow package.”